Growing down

IMO Rajesh framed where we are as a nation brilliantly. (Image below) And the startup vs sustainable business analogy for the nation took me into a meta direction.

I have seen variations of this theme in a bunch of different things I have read. Coincidentally, one in the book I was then reading – Amartya Sen’s The Idea of Justice.

The theme is versatile enough to cover a lot of things – and my examples are from justice, learning, and biology. The meta theme is about two different ways of navigating change. Keep the system intact and optimise within it. Or question whether the system itself still makes sense. 

Nīti vs Nyāya.

Homeostasis vs Allostasis.

Single-loop vs Double-loop learning

Very simplistically:

Nīti / Homeostasis / Single-loop: Maintain internal order by adjusting actions while keeping the underlying rules, goals and assumptions largely intact.

Nyāya / Allostasis / Double-loop: Maintain viability by questioning and changing those underlying rules, assumptions or goals when circumstances change.

When I think about it, at individual, org and country levels, the approach matters because in the first kind, we could become very good at solving the wrong problem. 

An individual can keep optimising productivity, promotions and income while ignoring health, relationships and whether this is what they really want in life. A startup chasing targets can keep optimising acquisition, conversion and fundraising while completely ignoring profitability, customer retention etc. A country can keep optimising the numbers it already knows how to measure, while the underlying story of its citizens tell a different tale.

And that brings us back to what we started with – how we frame the growth of a country. One immediate comparison is a neighbour’s Gross National Happiness. Despite its criticism, one of which is that it obscures economic stagnation, it at least tries to measure a multidimensional set of 33 objective capabilities (e.g. schooling, sanitation, governance, asset ownership etc) rather than treating economic output as the whole story. We’ve been, and seen it, and wondered how long it can keep the world out.

Given this, whether a country (or any system) is growing seems a secondary question to whether the rules by which it decides what “growth” means really represent our individual lives. How does one even do this at a country level? An election every 5 years seems hugely inadequate. 😐

P.S. I seem to have connected two of these a couple of years ago 🙂

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *